The second bout was against a "multi-bot"
called "Pack Raptor". The bot consisted of 2 identical bots that
would split apart and team up on their opponent. Several aspects of this
bot’s design blatantly violated the spirit of the rules for multi-bots,
but did adhere to the letter of the law by the narrowest of margins. In
its previous bout Pack Raptor squarely beat a fairly popular but weak bot
and was heavily booed when it was announced the winner. The multibot was
booed as it entered the arena, while T-Wrex was cheered. The bout was
billed as a replay of the ending of Jurassic Park, where the T-Rex beats
up on two Raptors to save the heroes. Fortunately history was not
re-written.
The bout started with Alain smashing both the bots with T-Wrex's tail.
Each hit resulted in the victim flying high in the air and landing some
distance away. The disadvantage of a multibot is that each individual bot
gives up substantial weight to its opponent and Alain took full advantage
of this. After one of the hits, one of the bots landed on its back and was
disabled. Alain went after the other bot and in the process both T-Wrex
and the remaining Raptor got entangled in the arena. At this point the
bout turned into the 2000 presidential election. You will need to put on
your lawyer hats to follow the action from this point forward.
Technically, since the bots were not entangled together, the referees
should not have intervened, but one of the referees decided to call a
time-out and free the two bots entangled in the arena. If this had not
happened, T-Wrex would have won because it was the last bot to loose its
movement. When the bout resumed, T-Wrex was not very responsive to the
control and it looked like we may get counted out. However, the referees
decided that since one half of the "Pack Raptor" was disabled,
they would declare that bot disabled and declare T-Wrex the winner by
knockout. The disability rules for multi-bots state that if "50% or
more" of the bot "by weight" is disabled, the whole bot is
declared disabled. Team Raptor appealed the decision on the basis that the
bot that was disabled was lighter of the two bots. They took the bots to
the official scale and had them weighed to prove their point. The judges
refused to accept the weights because the bots were not impounded after
the bout, so any weights taken later could not be guaranteed as reflecting
the weights during the bout. There was also the issue that the two bots
looked almost identical and so the judges were not even sure which bot was
the one that was disabled. The compromise decision was that the knockout
decision was set aside and the bout was sent to the judges as if it had
run its full 2 minutes. Because of the solid hits T-Wrex scored on its
opponents, T-Wrex was declared the winner by a comfortable margin. The
hour it took to reach the final decision felt a lot longer than the time
it took to decide the Florida election.
Because of the confusion and negative feelings between the teams, it
was not possible for us to take pictures of the Pack Raptors. We may try
and do that in the next day or two. We have agreed that if time and
schedule allows, we will request a televised grudge match between the two
bots. The organizers have so far downplayed the possibility of that
happening, but we will keep you posted. Once again kudos to Alain for a
great job driving and tossing around the opponents. [End of tournament
note: The following day the hard feelings were set aside and the teams
patched up their differences. In the mean time the Pack Raptors had been
packed away so we were unable to get any pictures]
Our next task was to figure out what went wrong with T-Wrex. It turned
out to be blown motor drivers. In trying to back out of being stuck under
the spike strips, the motor drivers blew. This was the second instance of
blown motors in the tournament (Omega-13 had motor failures yesterday). In
this case, the events preceding the failure (trying to back out while
stuck) and the failure mode (only the portion responsible for driving
backwards had failed) were well known. The failure was also localized to
only one chip per motor. Based on this new data, we were able to come up
with a theory of how the high current in the bots was causing the
controller in the motor driver to blow, when a higher current in the lab
had not caused any problems - the extra resistance and inductance of the
much longer cables and the connectors. Did I ever mention that both Brent
and I HATE connectors. Fortunately we had brought enough tools and spare
parts to diagnose the problem and fix the motors. The short-term fix is to
cut down the peak current on both bots (only Omega-13 had been cut back up
to this point). We believe it will not affect our performance in any
meaningful way and should keep us safe from similar failures for the rest
of the tournament.
With the technical and other problems of the day behind us, we called
it a day. We will be back at 8:30 tomorrow morning to make sure that the
bots are back together and we are ready to take on our next opponents in
front of cameras and hopefully in front of a national audience.
Will send you an update on Saturday's events, which we hope will be
just as full of success as this one and with fewer problems.
Hamid